Superior Insurance Agency

Superior Insurance Provides Auto Insurance, Home Insurance, Business Insurance, and more to Wilmington and all of North Carolina

 

 We save you time and money by comparing prices across multiple companies to get you the best rate. 

Get a superior quote

OUR Services

Auto

Whether you use your car to commute, for pleasure, or for business— we have full coverage and liability only policies to meet your needs.

Non-owners & Bonds

Want to get your licence but don’t have a car? Ask about our Named-non-owner’s policies. Need to register a vehicle but don’t have the title? Ask about our lost title bond MVR-92D.

Business

General Liability, Workers Comp, Commercial Auto, Bonds, and more!

Motorcycle, Boat & RV

Bundle your toys to maximize savings or start a stand-alone policy.

Homeowners & Renters

Flood, Wind, Landlord, Coastal, Homeowners, and Renters policies available.

Mobile Home

We can offer basic cost-conscious policies as well as more comprehensive mobile home policies. (Liability & theft options availible)

ABOUT Us

Real People

No need to fill out forms or navigate phone trees. When you call a licensed agent answers the phone. If you prefer to do business in person, come see us!

Over 50 Years of Experience

In addition to comparing rates, our agents know all the details to get you the coverage you want at the best price available.

A-rated Companies

We only work with insurance carriers that have an excellent ability to meet their ongoing insurance obligations.

Extended Hours

We understand that taking care of business during standard business hours isn’t always possible, we hope to better serve you by staying open until 7pm Monday through Saturday.

Better Choices

As an independent insurance agency we save you time and money giving you access to better choices by comparing prices across multiple companies to get you the best rate.

Flexible Financing

Whether you’re looking for a paid-in-full discount, automatic payments discount, or monthly bills in the mail — we’ve got financing options to fit your needs.

 

OUR TEAM

While each of our team members is unique, any available agent can help you with personal auto insurance or get you to the right department for other coverages.

Matthew Nakovich

Matthew Nakovich

Owner / Agent

Whitlee Nakovich

Whitlee Nakovich

Managing Partner / Agent

Joe Coffey

Joe Coffey

Homeowners Department / Agent

Jennifer Broglin

Jennifer Broglin

Commercial Department / Agent

Karen Strickland

Karen Strickland

Homeowners Department / Agent

Kris Davis

Kris Davis

Homeowners Department / Agent

Rosalynn Guzman

Rosalynn Guzman

Auto & Spanish Department / Agent

Ruby Guzman

Ruby Guzman

Auto Department / Agent

Griffin Nakovich

Griffin Nakovich

Auto Department / Agent

Eddie Guzman

Eddie Guzman

Auto Department / CSR

WHAT THEY’RE SAYING

  • 5 star review  Superior Insurance is such a warm and friendly place. Every time I go there I feel so at ease. The staff is awesome. I have had problems with my auto insurance but Superior is always there to get me through whatever mess I get myself into. Thank you Superior Insurance for caring do much about your customers. I give you 100 percent, you deserve it.

    thumb Deborah Price
    February 6, 2020

    5 star review  This is by far the best company I have ever used to get car insurance. Got an incredibly affordable rate for my new vehicle and I could not be happier. The customer service was incredible and very helpful. I would highly recommend using this company to anybody!

    thumb Matt Lambakis
    September 5, 2023

    5 star review  this is the best place that I have ever dealt with. you really get good rates and low payments that's affordable. my recommendation is to ask for Jennifer, she is awesome !!!!!! thanks Barry Grimes

    thumb Raekwon Gilliam
    December 31, 2019
  • 5 star review  Rosalynn helped me get a great price on a new auto insurance policy after finding out how much my premiums with Progressive were going up. She got us signed up with National General with a great rate. Rosalynn was very kind and pleasant to speak to, and I will definitely be using this company to reshop insurance next year! Thank you, Rosalynn!!

    thumb Jackie McNeil
    October 14, 2022

    5 star review  Ruby is very knowledgeable about insurance. Not only that but she is very polite & friendly! Also I witnessed Rosalyn help a dealer with a Spanish speaking customer on her day off! I recommend either of these ladies for your insurance needs!!!

    thumb Meredith Marchant
    July 27, 2024

    5 star review  Ruby is the best insurance agent! Always available and always manages to find me the best prices on policies! She makes getting insurance stress free

    thumb Lauren Gleaves
    September 21, 2022
  • 5 star review  Matt, has always handled my needs, my concerns, any of my changes, being very professional ,kind, n polite, n very quick in giving me any n all services that I had need of at there store: on Carolina Beach rd. Wilmington NC. And over the phone. He has personally gone over n above for all my concerns. If I could I would give him " 10 stars " not 5 his service as always been way above a 5 star.the whole Team is Great,been with them a few years, n have worked with Karen, n Roselyn n They Too have always been Great to work with . Caring polite, n quick to reach your needs

    thumb Vicki jo Owens
    August 27, 2025

    5 star review  Matt is a wonderful broker/agent/owner!! E sign is the most helpful tool I can get all my insurance from car to home at this location and sign all my documents from anywhere!! If you are paying to much or would just like to take a chance on a new agency this one you will be happy with!!

    thumb Odessa Ray
    January 15, 2020

    5 star review  This agency has some of the best customer service around. No automated system here. An actual, live person answers the phone! The homeowner agent, Kris Davis..... saved me hundreds on my house insurance! Add the fact they have extended business hours..... golden!

    thumb Tiff A
    March 26, 2019
  • 5 star review  My name is Allen R and I'm a sales representative at Neuwirth Motors. I'm always in the market for getting the best quotes for my customers who are buying new or used vehicles. Matt and his team are my number 1 go to. They've been phenomenal and have able to beat every other insurance quote I've received. Matt and his team is willing to go the extra mile to make sure they get every discount you qualify for. Which makes them a "Superior Insurance" company!! Thank you guys so much for the heart that you guys have. Its 100% transparent.!! You guys Rock!!

    thumb T Ronk
    December 29, 2019

    5 star review  Rosalyn Guzman was very helpful and knowledgeable for my insurance needs. Go to Superior Insurance for great service

    thumb Ruth Talent
    August 19, 2023

    5 star review  Ruby has been great and very helpful. I will recommend her and Superior Insurance to anyone. You guys have been great.

    thumb Cris
    September 17, 2025
  • 5 star review  When I go into the office I am always greeted with HI’s or Hello’s. If they are busy, they would tell me someone will be with me shortly. Everyone in the office always find the best insurance for their clients. They treat all their clients like family.

    thumb Leonor Hernandez
    June 29, 2022

    5 star review  Once again, Rosalyn was awesome over the weekend for mutual customers. This is a great company to work with as a customer and a dealer. I’ve referred multiple clients to them and every single one has been more than 100% satisfied

    thumb pj lucas
    November 7, 2022

    5 star review  A very good insurance company. Karen has been an excellent agent. She is pleasant, professional, and competent. Karen is prompt in her responses, and is able to answer any questions I may have. The entire staff is wonderful.

    thumb Anne Wagner
    November 21, 2023
  • 5 star review  Great people who treat you with respect and help you find the best insurance for the lowest price. I am extremely happy with the insurance and the friendly atmosphere at this place of business. Thank you for being there for me and my family.

    thumb Patrick Coleman
    October 13, 2018

    5 star review  Ruby was extremely helpful and did an awesome job finding me coverage at a lower cost. She is the so thorough and has the best personality

    thumb Jessie Reed
    July 23, 2024

    5 star review  My wife and I ate forever great full to Ruby who has helped us in talking to our insurance company which is national general and in helping us close a false claim that was made under our policy!!! Thank u so much Ruby for helping us u’re the best

    thumb shane hugh
    October 16, 2024
  • 5 star review  Fantastic agency! Everyone is friendly and have great personalities. Competitive insurance rates and they really go that extra mile! Highly recommend

    thumb Alicia Ludlow
    April 26, 2019

    5 star review  I really liked it, I was able to save more and they always give me excellent service, thank you very much for that.

    thumb Lil Birey
    October 12, 2024

    5 star review  The most helpful, real live people to help with your car insurance! Been with them for years and still always experience great support over the phone and in person! Quick to respond, resolve issues and email info as needed!

    thumb Jennifer Simpson
    July 26, 2025
  • 5 star review  These people are angels. As a new car owner going into insurance shopping in the dark, they helped explain everything to me and set me up with what was best. I couldn't find a better deal anywhere and within 45 minutes they had set me up on a policy even cheaper than who I was already with. They saved me thousands, but I'm more overjoyed that they saved my sanity. 2020 has been a nightmare of a year and Superior was a light in the darkness. I trust these guys more than I ever thought I could trust an insurance company but they are real, down to earth and care about their fellow human being- unlike other employees from other companies I had the displeasure of dealing with. Moral of the story: These guys WORK with you. They HELP you and they CARE. If you're unsure as to whether or not you should work with them- take it from someone who was on the verge of a full blown mental breakdown before calling them: Do it!! You won't regret it. Edit: Forgot to mention it was Mr. Matthew Nakovich I worked with and he is a sweetheart. He knows what he's doing and cares about what works for you. Best of all, he gives you OPTIONS. That's something I feel I barely get enough of these days. Thank you Matthew!!

    thumb Lexi
    September 28, 2020

    5 star review  Superior insurance has been my go to for the longest Rosalynn Guzman is by far the best, she’s very understanding and very easy to work with, your awesome Ms Guzman

    thumb kwon hansley
    November 14, 2024

    5 star review  I cannot recommend Superior insurance enough! All of the staff are helpful and nice. They were able to quote me a rate lower than any other agency I had tried. Matt and Karen are great, 10/10 recommend!

    thumb Morgan Bettenhausen
    October 28, 2022
  • 5 star review  They are the absolute best!! They work very well and are so professional! The help you receive from them is wonderful! Keep it up superior ? Karen and Jennifer have help me the most and I love them very much! Also the owner Matt is wonderful!!!

    thumb Ruth Law
    November 8, 2018

    5 star review  I'm very pleased with the service Superior Insurance Mr Matthew Nakovich is so helpful and patient polite and professional and always warm welcome, he saved me on lower payment plan I'm pleased with. His service all staff very helpful

    thumb Karen Warford
    August 26, 2025

    5 star review  5-star experience with Karen from Superior! She found us a great policy and saved us time from shopping around and comparing quotes. To make a long story short, she got us better coverage AND a better rate than we had before. I thought this process would be complicated because the property is sort of a unique situation, but she made it easy as 1-2-3. On top of that, she was a pleasure to work with. Definitely recommend!

    thumb Boys Real Estate
    May 23, 2024
  • 5 star review  Superior Insurance has the Best Popcorn in Wilmington,NC and we are Constanly Giving You Better Choices”Agents”

    thumb Matthew Nakovich
    September 10, 2021

    5 star review  Robert Hyman provided the best customer service we have ever received. He was so patient and informative. He saved us a great amount of money. I would recommend Superior Insurance to all.

    thumb Mary Mackey
    March 10, 2020

    5 star review  Amazing service! Rose was able to save me over $100/mo on my policy and was able to get me extra benefits. Cannot recommend Superior enough!

    thumb Kourtnie Souders
    July 3, 2024

Contact Us

In Person** & By Phone

2390 Carolina Beach Rd, Suite 101
Wilmington, NC 28401, USA

office +1 910 399 6628
fax +1 910 399 7495

**Due to COVID-19 we encourage you to wear a mask for in person visits or do business over the phone where possible, thank you!

Business Hours

Monday-Friday:
8:30am – 7:00pm

Saturday:
10:00am – 7:00pm

After-Hours Quotes

If you are at a dealership and need to start a new insurance policy outside of business hours please contact:

+1 336 301 3000

Superior Insurance

2390 Carolina Beach Rd #101, Wilmington, NC 28401

910-399-6628

Get in touch

Superior Insurance is one of the largest independent insurance agency chains with 25 offices in the state of North Carolina. This location is located in Wilmington, NC and serves all of North Carolina.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Get AN INSTANT ONLINE QUOTE FOR AUTO WITH DAIRYLAND

If our offices are closed and you can’t wait to get your coverage started, we can offer instant online quotes through Dairyland. Please be aware there may be lower rates available through one of our other insurance carriers, contact us to find out.

Dairyland Auto instant online quote